Islamic Educational Sciences
Mohammad Kawrani
”Educational concepts” in Islam are foundational and appear throughout Islamic texts. Many concepts surround upbringing (tarbiyah) and education under various headings, including spiritual purification (tazkiyah) and worship (ʿibādah). There are numerous, diverse books on these subjects: some suit non-Muslims, some suit beginners, and some suit only spiritual summits. Some of these concepts begin before a child is born and do not end with instructing the deceased (talqīn) or sending the reward of righteous deeds to the dead—they even include aiding a human being in the afterlife through supplication (duʿāʾ), the reward of deeds, and intercession (shafāʿah). This diversity matches the deeply complex nature of the human being, their spirit, and their soul. Here we note some of these concepts as points and observations, until a day comes when someone presents a comprehensive educational theory in a modern academic style. Among these Islamic concepts regarding upbringing and education, we mention the following:
1. Islam holds that upbringing is connected to a decisive concept—the afterlife—and to the Creator of the universe, who knows better than any creature what is in humanity’s best interest and benefit, and what harms or benefits them.
2. Islam holds that upbringing is connected to the concepts of this world (dunyā) and the hereafter (ākhirah), to truth (ḥaqq) and falsehood (bāṭil), and to the human being’s trajectory of growth and perfection from the beginning until the moment of death.
3. Islam bears no responsibility for the errors or impressions of any religion before it or any belief after it that deviated or strayed from it, because there is a difference between the true religion and a distorted religion.
4. Islam bears no responsibility for human mistakes in applying Islam or for the misuse of Islamic law (sharīʿah) by people; it is represented only by the spiritual summits who are infallible (maʿṣūm) against error and misapprehension.
5. Islam holds that upbringing is connected to two foundational concepts: human identity and the animal body, as well as human innate nature (fiṭrah) and animal instincts.
6. Islam holds that upbringing is connected to an inner struggle between the intellect (ʿaql) and the soul that commands to evil (al-nafs al-ammārah bi-l-sūʾ), as well as the forces of the intellect and the forces of the soul, and to what is called struggling against the self (jihād al-nafs) and the conflict between truth and falsehood.
7. Islam holds that human fiṭrah is exceedingly complex because it is composed of intellect and desire (shahwah) and possesses the power of choice or initiative between them. Fiṭrah is shaped by intellect and desire, by the conscious and subconscious, by body, spirit, and soul, by material and spiritual environments, and by the stages of the human journey across realms in the material world (nāsūt) or the unseen dominion (malakūt).
8. Islam holds that upbringing cannot be confined to material and worldly goals and aims alone; rather, there are matters far greater than this world and the material realm, as interests and benefits encompass the spirit and the hereafter.
9. Islam holds that educational goals and aims cannot be discovered without the help of the Creator and revelation (waḥy):
I. Because the human intellect suffers from two deficiencies and two kinds of ignorance: a relative ignorance of certain matters and an absolute ignorance of the afterlife.
II. Because the human intellect is affected by spiritual, social, environmental, and physical factors such as anger, fever, social pressure, love, and infatuation, among others.
III. Because the human intellect is influenced by society…
IV. Because God is the Creator of humanity, the universe, human fiṭrah, and the destiny of the cosmos, and He knows supreme interests best.
10. Islam believes that upbringing is such a complex process that the intellect alone cannot grasp all its dimensions; rather, a measure of submission (taslīm) to divine guidance is required, given God’s status as the Creator of human beings and the One who knows human nature.
11. Islam believes that the process of upbringing involves balanced dual equations—between fear and hope, belief and action, this world and the hereafter, compulsion and delegation (jabr and tafwīḍ), reward and punishment, and more.
12. Islam believes that upbringing encompasses many stages, including:
Stations of faith: Islam, submission, patience, intention, commanding good and forbidding evil, asceticism (zuhd), patience, sincerity (ikhlāṣ), reliance on God (tawakkul), and contentment (riḍā).
Degrees of faith: faith (īmān), worship, moral character, overcoming caprice and desires, diligence, perseverance, determination, and companionship with the righteous.
Moral traits, ranks of divine commands (wājib [obligatory], mustaḥabb [recommended], mubāḥ [permissible], makrūh [disliked], ḥarām [forbidden]), and ranks of faith in God (birr [righteousness], truthfulness, certainty, contentment, loyalty, knowledge, forbearance), as well as (Islam – Faith – Piety [taqwā] – Certainty) and (Faith as recognition in the heart, affirmation by the tongue, and action through the pillars).
13. Spiritual wayfaring (al-sayr wa-l-sulūk): This unfolds according to a person’s drive, resolve, and will toward perfection—yet its foundation lies in Islam and submission, then faith, then certainty (yaqīn): knowledge of certainty (ʿilm al-yaqīn), then vision of certainty (ʿayn al-yaqīn), then truth of certainty (ḥaqq al-yaqīn); or (Islam, faith, jihad, and migration [hijrah]—minor, major, and greatest); or intention and resolve.
14. Islamic upbringing is comprehensive, spanning from before birth to ongoing charity (ṣadaqah jāriyah) after death, and from general human upbringing for all people to the specialized spiritual training of the friends of God (awliyāʾ Allāh), as seen in Lubb al-Lubāb, al-Rūḥ al-Mujarrad, and Risālat al-Sayr wa-l-Sulūk by Allamah Tehrani.
15. Why do the West and the Zionist state insist on dictating school curricula for Palestinians—and even in Muslim countries…?
16. The Islamic educational curriculum is grounded in connection to revelation, the unseen, spiritual guardianship (wilāyah), and the ladder of piety (taqwā).
17. Educational sciences today are entangled in political struggles and used to justify old and new colonialism.
18. A person’s upbringing begins before birth and continues until after death. Among influential environments, the family holds immense importance in Islam—followed by the school, neighborhood, university, club, workplace, society, and beyond.
19. What do we learn? What do we teach, who has the right to decide that, and who is in a position to determine it?
20. Upbringing and education between reality and idealism, and between values and practical needs.
21. The factor of heredity and the capacity for choice—between compulsion and delegation, and the position “between the two positions” (al-amr bayn al-amrayn)—are among the factors affecting education from Islam’s perspective; even lineage/purity of birth (ḥilliyyat al-nasab) has an impact.
22. University profits, the labor market, and academic trends are what dictate the trajectory of higher education.
23. The best methods of upbringing and education between reality and ideals…
24. In Islam, moral values stand at high summits, and the path toward them is demanding; in the West, values often align with what a socially conditioned person desires, making moral slide and collapse easy—whereas the forces of the intellect support moral values and God unites His followers, while the forces of Satan are potent and sow division among his followers through his vices.
25. According to Islam, upbringing is transmitted:
First: through righteous action—such as lawful marriage (or its absence), or performing wuḍūʾ (ablution) during pregnancy and breastfeeding.
Second: through commands, words, and reinforcement.
Third: through encouragement and warning (targhīb wa-tarhīb).
Fourth: through doing good, observation, and imitation—such as not forbidding someone from eating dates while eating them yourself.
Fifth: through supplication and good intentions.
Sixth: through pure and corrupt spirits and souls.
Seventh: through unseen divine bestowal, for “knowledge is a light that God casts into the heart of whomever He wills.”
26. In Islam, the importance of upbringing in childhood within the family is like carving in stone.
27. Among the aims of education in Islam is that a child grow up with a sound body, sound mind, balanced soul, and elevated spirit, free from addiction and any disorder across spirit, soul, mind, and body—so they may freely choose good or evil with balanced capacities and conditions.
28. According to Islam, among the goals of upbringing and education is protecting the child and safeguarding youth—especially girls—from any imbalance that would make slipping into evil effortless and ascending to the peak of goodness nearly impossible, as we witness today with various forms of addiction.
Critical Topics on Modern Educational Sciences from the Perspective of Islamic Educational Sciences
1. Hypocrisy pervades Western educational sciences, where slogans point in one direction while all of society’s levers—wealth, power, media, thought, and social norms—pull in another.
2. Education in the West, contrary to its slogans, is governed by corrupt money.
3. Education in the West, contrary to its slogans, is governed by corrupt power and deviant Masonic currents.
4. Education in the West, contrary to its slogans, is governed by corrupt media.
5. Education in the West speaks of certain ideals while cultural and intellectual elites move in another direction—look at the ruling Masonic currents.
6. Education in the West speaks of certain ideals while society moves in another direction—look at who distributes cocaine in Black communities in America.
7. Education in the West treats parents’ customs and traditions, society, and existing norms as the ideal, so amid other pressures everything trends downward into decline—whereas Islamic upbringing holds high summits and a continuous upward striving alongside a struggle against falsehood.
8. Modern educational sciences treat all religions, beliefs, theories, and movements as equal, never distinguishing between the reality of a “true religion, true school of thought, and true belief”—because of interreligious disputes and bloody conflicts, they drop the challenging question from discussion instead of analyzing it.
9. All serious critiques of modern human sciences—especially psychology and sociology—apply to modern educational sciences:
First: As scholars themselves acknowledge, the humanities are not purely objective readings of facts; they also carry presuppositions.
Second: Adherents of experimental tools in the humanities achieve notable technical findings, yet behind those tools lies a dangerous assumption—that the humanities are material sciences because experimental tools are material and sensory—which subconsciously poses a grave threat to humanity and to these disciplines.
Third: Every scholar holds some faith or creed; when humanities scholars and theorists treat all religions as equal with no true or false faith, there is a grave underlying assumption—that earlier revealed religions are false and arbitrary new beliefs are free of the contradictions attributed to revealed faiths.
Fourth: There are major, essential critiques of all current humanities and theoretical frameworks; if examined—as they must be—those disciplines lose any claim to absolute credibility.
Fifth: So long as no alternative exists to these current humanities and theoretical frameworks, they cannot simply be abandoned.
Sixth: As Muslims, we regard whatever is complete and free of defect as Islamic; therefore, when we attribute Islam to a science, human trait, or human act, our aim is to point to its completeness and its freedom from the flaws and contradictions found in its counterparts.
Seventh: The chief obstacle to discussing this issue is that the positives of Western humanities have blinded minds and hearts so that no one can debate their serious weaknesses or seek an alternative—even though those positives are heavily inflated by power, money, and media.
10. All Western criticisms leveled against Islamic educational sciences stem from the domination of outsiders, the corrupt, and tyrants (ṭawāghīt), followed by Western colonialism over Muslim peoples and the ouster of the righteous and virtuous from governance. Therefore, the supreme goals of Islamic education will not be fully realized until global justice is established through avenging the blood of the one slain at Karbala—which in turn is realized only through the true emergence of the Qāʾim (Ḥujjah, may God hasten his reappearance) and the state of truth, to which the noble verse of the Quran refers: “And God will complete His light, even though the disbelievers dislike it.” We believe that the state of truth leads to the true, ideal Islamic civilization—one unlike any civilization the world has seen.
11. Knowledge and upbringing are not transmitted merely through books, texts, and words: a corrupt or psychologically unwell teacher cannot be a good educator for children and individuals, just as a sick environment and society cannot open real space for goodness to shape the learner, even if they have memorized every science.
12. The destructive role of international/UN bodies and globalization.
13. The destructive role of old and new missionary and colonial institutions.
14. Many Western scholars do not consider education a true science, but rather a collection of experiments. Given that the instrument of knowledge in Western humanities—including educational sciences—is experimentation, it is hardly a science in the strict sense, as it shifts from teacher to teacher, school to school, neighborhood to neighborhood, city to city, and country to country. Educational sciences have also passed through varying phases, and whenever a phase faltered, its rules were altered and adjusted—until some humanities scholars claimed that the humanities are sciences with shifting, changeable rules, which is one of the most absurd theories imaginable about science.
https://mohammadabbaskawrani.com
#BrightFutureIslamicCivilization #Merciful_Dignified_Civilization #IslamicHumanities
