Three “Stupid” Questions About Islamic Humanities!
Mohammad Kawrani | September 14, 2026
When ignorance of the philosophy of science turns into a philosophy for defending the status quo!
Three questions keep resurfacing whenever the idea of Islamic humanities is raised—as if those asking them had just declared the end of scientific debate. Yet in reality, these questions only expose a striking confusion between science and its sources, between knowledge and its ideologies, and between respecting science and deifying human output!
Question One: “Science is science—religion has nothing to do with it!”
Oh, how convenient! Did science descend from the sky with no scientists, no institutions, no universities, no budgets, no philosophies, and no economic or political interests?!
We are not claiming that a scientific fact changes according to the religion of whoever discovers it. Rather, we are talking about the intellectual and value framework that determines what is worth researching, what questions get asked, what studies get funded, what findings get commercialized, and to what end knowledge is put.
Is psychology detached from its practitioner’s view of what a human being is? Is sociology free of social philosophy? Is economics devoid of assumptions about ownership, justice, profit, and distribution? Is law separate from moral philosophy? Are educational studies independent of a vision of humanity and society?
Science may be objective in its tools, yet choosing its subjects, steering its applications, and defining its ends are not necessarily neutral matters.
So no one is calling for an “Islamic multiplication table” or altering the laws of physics by denomination! We are talking about the Islamic character of vision, methodology, ends, and values within the humanities—and about reconstructing knowledge concerning human beings and society upon an Islamic vision of existence, humanity, dignity, justice, and responsibility.
Question Two: “Current sciences aren’t Western!”
Really? Did they fall out of the sky, or were they born in a civilizational vacuum bearing no cultural or philosophical imprint?!
Anyone who denies the sweeping Western influence in shaping modern universities, humanities curricula, psychological and sociological schools, economic and political theories, and institutions of research, publishing, and academic ranking needs to revisit the history of science before handing out certificates of ignorance to others!
We are not saying that all modern knowledge is Western in origin, nor are we denying the contributions of Islamic, Greek, Indian, Chinese, or other civilizations, nor claiming that every Western theory is wrong.
Yet does denying Western historical and institutional dominance over global academic production make that dominance vanish?!
And does translating Western theories into Arabic, teaching them in our universities, repeating their terminology, and stamping them with a local seal automatically turn them into neutral sciences free of philosophical baggage?
The problem is not benefiting from the West—it is turning benefit into dependency, and turning human theories into axioms beyond critique.
Question Three: “Current sciences are sacred!”
Now we have reached the pinnacle of academic comedy! If current sciences were sacred, why do scientific peer reviews exist? Why are theories revised? Why do curricula change? Why do scholars compete to refute one another’s hypotheses? And why are errors uncovered decades after theories were adopted and taught?
Have scientists become infallible prophets? Have universities turned into temples? Have scientific theories become scriptures immune to criticism?
True science is not afraid of questions, does not need ideological bodyguards to shield it from critique, and does not ask a researcher to bow before a European or American name simply because it carries a prestigious academic title.
Deifying human science is, in truth, a betrayal of science itself—because science advances through critique, correction, comparison, and the search for truth, not through intellectual subservience.
We Are Not a Project Hostile to Modern Science
Islamic humanities is not a project aimed at opposing modern science, erasing the achievements of other civilizations, or replacing scholarly inquiry with religious sermons. It is a project to liberate the humanities from the monopoly of specific philosophical, material, and ideological outlooks—and to re-examine human beings, society, economics, politics, law, and education through an integrated Islamic worldview and ethic.
We want to ask: Who defines the goals of science? Who steers research? Who sets priorities? Who reaps the benefits? What kind of human being do we want to shape? And what kind of society do we want to build?
If asking such questions is considered stepping outside of science, the problem does not lie with the Islamic humanities project—it lies with those who want science to be free in every respect except the freedom to critique their own ideas!
https://mohammadabbaskawrani.com
#BrightFutureIslamicCivilization #IslamicHumanities
